Electric Vs Propane Smoker: Which is Best for You?

Electric Vs Propane Smoker: Which is Best for You?

Smokers are a popular way to cook food. There are two main choices: electric smokers and propane smokers. Now the million-dollar question is – who wins in the Electric vs Propane Smoker debate? Both have their pros and cons, and it can be hard to decide which one is right for you.

Electric smokers are a great smoker option for those who are looking for an easy smoking experience. With little to no charcoal or wood needed, electric smokers make it easy to set and forget your food, resulting in perfectly smoked dishes every time. 

However, propane smokers are still a popular choice for many backyard chefs due to their affordability and the wide variety of Smoker models available on the market today. So, which is the best smoker type for you? Let’s take a closer look at the differences between electric and propane smokers to help you decide!

Difference Between The Electric And Propane Smoker

  • The most obvious difference between propane and electric smokers is the fuel source. Propane smokers use, well, propane – either from a small tank or hooked up to a larger one – while electric smokers need to be plugged into an outlet.
  • Another big difference between propane and electric smokers is temperature control. Most electric smokers come with built-in temperature controls, so it’s easy to set and maintain the perfect cooking temperature. Propane smokers, on the other hand, can be more difficult to control. If you’re not careful, it’s easy to end up with food that’s either undercooked or burnt.

It really depends on your needs and preferences. If you want the convenience of electric smoking or need to save space, an electric smoker might be the way to go. But if you prefer the traditional feel of smoking with propane or want more control over the cooking temperature, a propane smoker could be a better choice. 

Electric Smoker: Everything You Need To Know

Electric smokers use electricity to heat wood chips or pellets that are placed in a tray inside the smoker. The heat from the wood chips or pellets produces smoke that flavors food as it cooks. Electric smokers are simple to use and require very little maintenance, making them a great option for those who want to enjoy smoked foods without all the hassle.

One of the main benefits of using an electric smoker is that they’re very efficient. They don’t require as much wood as traditional smokers, so you’ll save money on fuel costs. Electric smokers are also very easy to set up and use, so you can get smoking right away without having to fiddle with a lot of equipment.

One of the drawbacks is that electric smokers don’t produce the same intense smoke flavor that you’ll get from charcoal or wood-fired smokers. But if you’re looking for an easy-to-use smoker that doesn’t require a lot of hassle, an electric smoker may be the right choice for you.

Electric Smoker Pros:

  • You can set it and forget it: Most electric smokers come with a thermostat that you can set to your desired temperature. Once the smoker reaches that temperature, it will maintain it there until you’re ready to take your food off.
  • They’re very consistent: Because electric smokers rely on set temperatures, they’re much more consistent than other types of smokers. This is especially important if you’re smoking something like meat, which can be easily ruined if not cooked evenly.
  • They’re easy to use: Electric smokers are pretty much as plug-and-play as you can get. You don’t need to worry about things like ventilation or fuel; just set it up, turn it on, and let it do its.

Electric Smoker Cons:

  • Electric smokers can be more expensive than propane smokers.
  • They can also be less portable since they need to be plugged into an outlet.
  • Some people find electric smokers harder to use, as they can be difficult to control the temperature on.
  • If there is a power outage, you won’t be able to use your electric smoker.
  • They don’t produce as much smoke as a propane smoker.
  • The repair of electric smokers can be difficult or a bit complicated and expensive.

Propane Smoker: A Brief Introduction

If you’re looking for an easy-to-use smoker that will give your food a delicious smoky flavor, then a propane smoker is the way to go. Propane smokers are simple to set up and use, and they’re very efficient at smoking meats and other foods.

Propane smokers come in all shapes and sizes, from small tabletop models to large freestanding units. Most propane smokers have two or three compartments: a firebox where you light the burner, a water pan to add moisture and help regulate temperature, and a cooking chamber where the food is placed. 

Some smokers also have a separate compartment for wood chips, which gives the food an even smokier flavor. Let’s look at the pros and cons of owning a propane smoker!

Propane Smoker Pros:

  • They’re very versatile: Propane smokers can be used for both hot and cold smoking, so they’re perfect if you want to smoke a variety of foods.
  • They’re easy to control: Unlike some other types of smokers, propane smokers allow you to easily control the temperature inside the smoker. This means that you can cook your food exactly how you want it, without having to worry about things like uneven cooking or overcooked or undercooked meat.
  • They’re relatively portable: Propane smokers are usually smaller and lighter than other types of smokers, making them easier to transport if you want to take your smoker with you on a camping trip or to a friend’s house.

Propane Smoker Cons:

  • There may be some issues with performance during bad weather because this smoker generally isn’t well insulated.
  • The process of refilling your propane tank can be difficult, especially in areas without propane dealers
  • The temperature inside your chamber is harder to control when it runs too hot, particularly with off-brand manufacturers.

Electric Smokers and Propane Smokers – Head-to-head

Electric Smokers Vs Propane Smokers

The decision to consider one thing better over another comes down to personal preference as with a lot in life. Some people believe electric smokers are better than propane smokers, while others think propane smokers are the best choice.

If you still have not finalized your decision, here are some factors that help to finalize which one is best for you.

1. Cost

Electric smokers are typically more expensive than propane smokers. However, they’re also more energy-efficient and easier to use. If you’re looking for a smoker that’s easy to operate and doesn’t require a lot of supervision, an electric smoker is a good choice.

Propane smokers are less expensive than electric smokers, but they’re not as energy-efficient. They’re also more difficult to use, so if you’re new to smoking meats, a propane smoker may not be the best choice.

2. Easy To Use

Electric smokers are by far the easiest type of smoker to use. Simply plug in the smoker, set the temperature, and let it do its thing. Propane smokers require a bit more work. You’ll need to light the smoker and make sure there is enough propane in the tank. 

You’ll also need to regulate the temperature manually, which can be tricky. But once you get the hang of it, propane smokers are just as easy to use as electric ones.

3. Bad Weather Considerations

When it comes to electric vs propane smokers, one of the key considerations is how each type will perform in bad weather. If you live in an area with severe winters, then an electric smoker may not be the best option as it can’t withstand sub-zero temperatures. 

Propane smokers, on the other hand, are built to withstand colder temperatures and will perform better in winter weather. Another consideration is wind; if you live in a windy area, an electric smoker may be the better choice. 

4. Reliability

When it comes to electric vs propane smokers, reliability is an important consideration. Electric smokers are more reliable than propane smokers because they don’t require fuel and there is no risk of a fire. Propane smokers can be less reliable because the fuel can run out or the smoker can catch on fire.

Electric Smoker Brands

So, if you’re looking for an electric smoker, then be sure to check out the top brands. Masterbuilt and Char-Broil are two of the best on the market today.


Masterbuilt is one of the leading manufacturers of electric smokers. They have a wide variety of models to choose from, so you can find one that fits your needs perfectly. Additionally, Masterbuilt offers a great warranty on their products, so you can be sure that your investment is protected.

If you are willing to buy a Masterbuilt Electric Smoker, don’t forget to read the ultimate reviews here.


Char-Broil is another excellent choice when it comes to electric smokers. They offer a variety of models as well, so you can find one that suits your needs. Char-Broil also has a great warranty on their products, so you can be sure that you’re getting a quality product.

Propane Smoker Brands

Camp Chef offers a variety of propane smokers to choose from, so you can find the perfect one for your needs. Cuisinart also has a few different models to choose from, so you can find the right one for your cooking style. Smoke Hollow offers a wide selection of propane smokers, so you’re sure to find the perfect one for your needs.

Camp Chef and Cuisinart are both great choices if you’re looking for quality and value. Smoke Hollow is a great choice if you’re looking for a wide selection of smokers.


Is an Electric Smoker worth it?

Electric smokers are a great way to enjoy smoking without having to deal with the hassle of traditional smokers. They’re easy to use and produce great results, making them worth the investment for many people.

Should I soak my wood chips for an Electric Smoker?

It’s generally not necessary to soak wood chips before using them in an electric smoker. However, soaking them for 30-60 minutes can help to produce more smoke, and may be worth trying if you’re having trouble getting enough smoke from your smoker.

Propane Smoker vs. Electric Smoker: Who Wins The Race?

When it comes to electric vs propane smokers, there is no clear winner. Both have their advantages and disadvantages. Electric smokers are typically more expensive, but they are also easier to use and provide more consistent results. Propane smokers require more maintenance, but they are less expensive and can be used in a wider range of temperatures. 

Ultimately, the decision of which type of smoker to purchase depends on personal preferences and needs.

5/5 - (1 vote)